🐾 Built for Normie first

Handmade pumpkin treats dogs will work for.

Four recognizable ingredients. Baked in small batches. Crunchy enough for a special reward and easy to break up for training or enrichment.

Buy 2 bags, get your 3rd 50% off automatically

Choose your bag → 30-day money-back guarantee · Handmade in Minnesota · Free shipping $39.99+
PuzzlePup Pumpkin Peanut Butter Cookies pouch with puzzle-piece treats
🎃 Real pumpkin🥜 Organic peanut butter🌾 Gluten-free oat flour🚫 No artificial junk

Choose the right bag for your pup

Add three qualifying bags and Shopify automatically takes 50% off the third. No code needed.

25-count bag

$14.99
About 60¢ per treat
  • Easy first bag
  • Great for training and everyday rewards
  • 4.4 oz
Best value

40-count bag

$19.99
About 50¢ per treat
  • 20% lower cost per treat
  • Best for daily training and enrichment
  • 7 oz
Automatic offer: buy any 2 qualifying treat bags and get the 3rd bag 50% off.
See full product details and customer reviews
PuzzlePup treat ingredients: pumpkin, oat flour, organic peanut butter, and molasses

Nothing weird. Just four simple ingredients.

The same recipe made for my Helping Paws service dog, Normie—without fillers, artificial flavors, or mystery extras.

✓Real pumpkin for wholesome flavor and dog-friendly fiber.
✓Gluten-free oat flour as a gentle, wheat-free base.
✓Organic peanut butter for the flavor dogs go wild for.
✓Molasses for a small touch of natural sweetness.

One bag. Plenty of good-dog moments.

The crunchy puzzle-piece shape works across your dog’s day.

🎓Training rewards

Break them into smaller pieces for quick, repeatable wins.

🧩Snuffle enrichment

Hide them in a mat and turn snack time into nose work.

🐕Everyday treats

A simple reward you can feel good about reaching for.

💙Bonding breaks

Celebrate the small moments with a satisfying crunch.

Handmade for my service dog. Shared with yours.

Every batch is baked by hand in small runs—the same treats I make for Normie. If I would not give it to him, it does not go in the bag.

Choose your bag →
Normie waiting for a handmade PuzzlePup cookie held by a light-skinned hand
★★★★★

“My dogs love this treat! And I feel good about supporting a local business.”

Verified PuzzlePup customer
What ingredients are in the treats?

Real pumpkin, gluten-free oat flour, organic peanut butter, and molasses.

Do these treats contain peanuts?

Yes. These treats contain organic peanut butter and are not suitable for dogs or households avoiding peanuts.

How does the three-bag offer work?

Add three qualifying treat bags to the cart. The third bag is automatically discounted 50%—no code needed.

What if my dog does not love them?

Your order is backed by PuzzlePup’s 30-day money-back guarantee.

Ready for the tail-wag test?

Pick the 25-count starter bag or the 40-count best value. Add three bags to unlock the automatic offer.

Choose your bag →

Allergen information: contains peanuts. These products are homemade and not subject to state inspection.

From $14.99Choose a bag