25-count bag
$14.99
About 60¢ per treat
- Easy first bag
- Great for training and everyday rewards
- 4.4 oz
Three 25-count bags come to $37.48 with the third half off — and that ships free.
🐾 Built for my service dog, Normie. Perfected for yours.
Choose your bag → 30-day money-back guarantee · Handmade in Minnesota · Free shipping $34.98+
The four-ingredient reward your dog will actually work for.
You should not have to choose between a treat your dog wants and a label you understand. These crunchy puzzle pieces are handmade with real pumpkin, gluten-free oat flour, organic peanut butter, and molasses—nothing else.
★★★★★5.0· 19 verified reviews
Buy 2 bags, get your 3rd 50% off automatically
Choose your bag → 30-day money-back guarantee · Handmade in Minnesota · Free shipping $34.98+
4️⃣ Exactly four ingredients🏠 Handmade in Minnesota✂️ Easy to break for training🚫 No artificial colors or flavors
Choose the right bag for your pup
Add three qualifying bags and Shopify automatically takes 50% off the third. No code needed.
40-count bag
$19.99
About 50¢ per treat
- 20% lower cost per treat
- Best for daily training and enrichment
- 7 oz
Two 40-count bags = $39.98 and ships free. Three = $49.98 with the third half off, also free shipping.
3 × 40-count · $49.98Third bag 50% off · ships free · one clickSnuffle Mat + 25-count treats · $39.99Save $4.99 vs buying separately · ships free
Automatic offer: buy any 2 qualifying treat bags and get the 3rd bag 50% off. Free shipping starts at $34.98.
See full product details and customer reviews
What owners say about the treats
Verified reviews collected via Judge.me from real PuzzlePup orders.
★★★★★5.0 out of 5· 19 reviews
★★★★★
“My dogs love this treat! And I feel good about supporting a local business.”
Rebecca MacKenzieVerified
★★★★★
“They break easy so you can give little pieces while training, or give them whole as a special treat.”
Mark and Sarah KippVerified
★★★★★
“My dog loves them. He is a small dog — about 10 pounds, so I break them into smaller pieces.”
Barbara JerabekVerifiedFour ingredients. You can see every one.
No mystery blend and no wall of label copy—just the complete recipe, shown ingredient by ingredient.
Real pumpkin
Whole-food flavor + naturally occurring fiber
Why it is here
It gives every batch recognizable pumpkin flavor without an artificial pumpkin flavoring.
Gluten-free oat flour
The wheat-free, crunchy base
Why it is here
It creates the baked crunch and helps each puzzle piece break into smaller training rewards.
Organic peanut butter
The aroma dogs notice first
Why it is here
It makes the reward smell and taste exciting to dogs. Contains peanuts.
Molasses
Helps bind + lightly sweeten
Why it is here
A small amount rounds out the recipe and helps create the baked texture without artificial sweeteners.
That is the complete ingredient list: pumpkin, gluten-free oat flour, organic peanut butter, and molasses. Contains peanuts.
Why this bag over another treat?
Choose the four-ingredient bag →
Because “my dog likes it” should not be the only standard.
A useful reward has three jobs: motivate your dog, fit the moment, and give you confidence in what you are feeding. PuzzlePup does all three without a long, hard-to-decipher label.
What matters
PuzzlePup
Check another bag
Ingredient clarity
Exactly 4, all named
How long is the label?
Artificial colors or flavors
None
Varies by recipe
Reward flexibility
Whole or easy to break
Will it portion cleanly?
How it is made
Handmade, small batch
Is the process disclosed?
Try-it protection
30-day guarantee
What is the return policy?
Make the bag last longer
Hide them in a Snuffle Mat.
Scattered across the mat, a handful of treats turns a ten-second snack into a proper sniff-and-search job. One owner reported their dog’s eating time went from about a minute to closer to fifteen.
The Enrichment Bundle is $39.99 — the mat plus a 25-count bag. Bought separately that is $44.98, so the bundle saves $4.99 and ships free.
Choose the job
One bag earns its place all day.
Tap the moment you are buying for. The same crunchy puzzle piece can become a fast training reward, a longer sniffing activity, or a simple ritual your dog recognizes.
🎓 “I need a reward that works for training.”
Break one cookie into smaller pieces so your dog gets more repetitions without stopping the session for a large biscuit.
🧩 “I need something that makes enrichment easier.”
Scatter pieces through a Snuffle Mat to turn the reward into a sniff-and-search job instead of a ten-second handout.
🐕 “I want a daily treat I understand.”
Four named ingredients, a clear peanut allergen disclosure, and no artificial colors or flavors make the label easy to evaluate.
💙 “I want a small ritual my dog gets excited about.”
The peanut-butter aroma, crunchy texture, and puzzle shape create a recognizable reward moment worth waiting for.
Built for my service dog, Normie. Perfected for yours.
Every batch is baked by hand in small runs—the same treats I make for Normie. If I would not give it to him, it does not go in the bag.
Choose your bag →
Common questions
What ingredients are in the treats?
Real pumpkin, gluten-free oat flour, organic peanut butter, and molasses. That is the complete recipe.
Why choose these over an ordinary dog biscuit?
PuzzlePup Cookies give you a short, fully named ingredient list; no artificial colors or flavors; a crunchy piece that can be served whole or broken for training; handmade small-batch production; and a 30-day money-back guarantee.
Are they soft or crunchy?
They are crunchy. The puzzle pieces can also be broken into smaller rewards for training, small dogs, or Snuffle Mat enrichment.
Do these treats contain peanuts?
Yes. These treats contain organic peanut butter and are not suitable for dogs or households avoiding peanuts.
How does the three-bag offer work?
Add three qualifying treat bags to the cart. The third bag is automatically discounted 50%—no code needed.
How do I get free shipping?
Orders of $34.98 or more ship free. Every three-bag order clears it: three 25-count bags come to $37.48 and three 40-count bags come to $49.98. Two 40-count bags at $39.98 ship free as well.
How long do the treats keep a dog busy?
On their own, seconds. Scattered through a Snuffle Mat, considerably longer — one owner reported their dog went from about a minute to closer to fifteen.
What if my dog does not love them?
Your order is backed by PuzzlePup’s 30-day money-back guarantee.
Ready for the tail-wag test?
Pick the 25-count starter bag or the 40-count best value. Three 40-count bags come to $49.98 with the third half off — and ship free.
Choose your bag →Allergen information: contains peanuts. These products are homemade and not subject to state inspection.
★ 5.0 · From $14.99Choose a bag
Handmade treats · from $14.99Choose 25 or 40 treats
Choose bag